Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Craig Barker's avatar

So, a contextual note: There is a LOT of debate right now over whether summer work is a). effective and b). whether it is classist. The research suggests that giving students work to do before you, as the teacher, have had a chance to establish your expectations and norms for the class actually can make it harder to build relationships, because students are less likely to reach out with questions or concerns over the summer regarding the work, whereas they might be willing to do so in the context of a school year. I tried giving a simple 200 word vocabulary list of words that show up in AP history classes that are not content specific and I would give a quiz on the first Friday of the school year. It would end up tanking almost everyone's grade and I ended up having to answer a whole bunch of emails about it and decided it wasn't worth it. BUT in one of my professional learning communities, there's been an excellent idea that many of us have adopted in an effort to bring some sanity to the academic arms race: "No work on vacation days" which is to say "If I'm off work, you're off work." I don't want to be grading when I am on winter break, spring break, or over the summer, I should not ask students to do the same. And my results on the AP exam are no better or worse than they were before. So I don't begrudge anyone who gives summer homework, but I would ask them to elucidate their why.

Expand full comment
DevilGrad's avatar

Wow, it's hard to pick just one teacher, but I will be forever grateful to my elementary teacher for her response to me dropping out of second grade. (No, seriously, I jumped out the second-floor classroom window into a bush and walked home because I was bored.) It would have been easier for her punish me or send me off for some sort of diagnosis, which wouldn't have been entirely unwarranted. Instead, she got the school's speech teacher to create a DIY enriched reading program for me and two other kids. I was going to school in a really small town with an underresourced school and no such thing as a "gifted program." But I spent the rest of elementary school doing reading in a converted office in the bus garage working my way through every Caldecott and Newbery awarded book ever written. It was great -- and most of my classmates never figured out what we were doing over there.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts